Children as young as 1 are commonly told that they should share their toys, especially in environments like preschool & daycare settings. We commonly find others or ourselves saying dialogues like:
“Sharing is caring.”
“You are a good boy/girl right? Share your toys.”
“Sharing is easy.”
“You must share your toys.”
“They will play with you only if you share.”
In most situations the child is protesting. Many times, in spite of that, the toy is taken away from the child and handed over to someone else. This particularly can happen at Preschools, nursery school in Pune or our own household.
For toddlers who haven’t yet formed their independent sense of self, an act of giving a toy to someone else could range anywhere from feeling undesirable to traumatic.
In the long run, this could result in not feeling seen, not feeling valued, helplessness, not feeling safe in the presence of the caregiver, not being able to trust, low self worth, low self esteem, people pleasing habits & so on.
Also, sharing is NOT caring. Sharing isn’t a certificate of being good. Anyone can share anything if & when they are comfortable. The boundaries of an individual, even a toddler, need to be respected.
Note: The concern of parents around when & how the child will learn to share children toys is a valid one. There is plenty of time for the toddler to learn sharing, not from a space of wanting to look good but from the space of genuine compassion.
Activity:
When you find yourself insisting that your child should share, take a deep breath and step back from the urge to say anything.
Ask your child if they want to share. If the child says ‘no’ back off.
Make sure you don’t judge your child through your words or your body language for not sharing.
Creative solutions:
Wait for your child to lose interest in that particular toy, engage the other child with something else till then.
Create an interesting play involving the children toys in question, the child who is waiting for the sharing to happen and your child. See if you can ease your child into playing together with that toy and with another child in a creative, fun way.
Create another exciting distraction for both your child and the other child and help them both engage with something else altogether. Aajol has introduced the concept of playing turn by turn allowing children to share toys voluntarily making it one of the best preschool near me.
Respect your child’s resistance. Remember, no lessons can be imparted through force.